The last time the EC and the government had a quarrel

Poll reforms should begin with the Election Commission

canada goose jacket outlet toronto For successive governments the Election Commission remains a cow where unhealthy precedents are allowed to be nurtured since Independence, says N Sathiya Moorthy. canada goose jacket outlet toronto

canada goose outlet orlando Image: President Ram Nath Kovind with Chief Election Commissioner OP Rawat during the 8th National Voters Day celebrations in New Delhi on January 25, 2018. Photograph: PTI Photo. canada goose outlet orlando

canada goose factory outlet toronto location The appointment of Om Prakash Rawat as the chief election commissioner and another veteran civil servant, Ashok Lavasa, as election commissioner, has once again kick started a muted discourse and animated accusations about the very process behind such appointments. canada goose factory outlet toronto location

canada goose outlet boston Stung by the disqualification of 20 of its MLAs, the Aam Aadmi Party has also turned the gun on the Election Commission. canada goose outlet boston

canada goose outlet mall As if this was not enough, Prime Minister Narendra Modi added a new dimension to all talks on electoral reforms by reviving an old suggestion for polls to Parliament and state assemblies, on the pleas of cost cutting, time wastages and policy distractions. canada goose outlet mall

canada goose outlet in montreal He has since followed it up, asking his Bharatiya Janata Party chief ministers and others to kick start a national debate on the subject. President Ram Nath Kovind too flagged the point in his address to Parliament, since. canada goose outlet in montreal

canada goose outlet in vancouver Coming as it does from the incumbent government at the Centre, PM Modi suggestion needs to be debated on merit, and debated for merit, as there are minor aspects of electoral reforms that hit at the root of EC accountability and, more so, credibility. It relates to the very appointment of election commissioners and the chief election commissioner. canada goose outlet in vancouver

canada goose outlet miami Truth be told, no party or leader wants to question the EC or the appointment or impartiality of commissioners in a nation where periodic elections in some state or the other has become the order of uk canada goose the day. The last time the EC and the government had a quarrel, Prime Minister P V Narasimha Rao went on to expand the commission to make it a three member affair from the existing one member scheme since the nation became a Republic. Offended incumbent EC, T N Seshan, went to court, challenging this change, but even he did not contest the mode and norms of appointments per se, lest his appointment too would have been questioned, ab initio. canada goose outlet miami

canada goose outlet online At a time when governments and prime ministers, especially incumbent Modi and immediate predecessor Manmohan Singh, were talking tall on reforms and also the possibilities of professionalising sector wise administration of government departments and public corporations through the induction and/or elevation of domain experts and in house technocrats, for successive governments the Election Commission alone remains a cow where unhealthy precedents since Independence are allowed to be nurtured. canada goose outlet online

canada goose outlet real While the Election Commission is a constitutional body, with a permanent staffing pattern internally at higher levels, and massive part time induction/diversion of public servants at all levels for election time duties, starting with door to door enrolment of voters to the actual conduct of balloting, most Election Commissioners and Chief Election Commissioners have come invariably from the civil service. Of the 22 CECs (or one man ECs before them) including incumbent Rawat, only three S P Sen Verma, R V S Peri Sastri and V S Remadevi were/are not civil servants. canada goose outlet real

canada goose outlet near me None Canada Goose Jackets of them have had much experience in Election Commission work, other than while serving as district magistrates/district collectors, or as the home secretary, among others, canada goose clearance in their parent state. Invariably, accusations of Canada Goose Coats On Sale appointments have flown thick and fast almost on every canada goose clearance sale occasion. Neither the cheap canada goose uk Janata Parivar (1977 80), nor the National Front (1989 90/91), or the later day United Front (1996 98), Canada Goose Outlet all of which swore to reform the nation administration, including electoral administration, did anything different from the and corrupting influence of the Congress. canada goose outlet near me

canada goose shop uk Two BJP prime ministers, Atal Bihari Vajpayee (1998 2004) canada goose outlet and now Narendra Modi were happy talking reforms until coming to power, but have not followed Canada Goose Online up on their promises afterward when alone it canada goose factory sale matters. canada goose shop uk

canada goose outlet paypal The Election Commission is not the only institution that is crying for reforms at the very induction stage of the Election Commissioners and the elevation of one among them (thus far) as CEC. The Comptroller and Auditor General is another constitutional office, which has a huge network of officials auditing the accounts of every paisa spent from the Consolidated Fund of India and the rest, and yet incumbents are all ad hoc appointees, giving room for flexibility and possible partiality in the choice, accompanied by avoidable controversies. At least since the Bofors scam Canada Goose sale and HWD submarine deal expose by T N Chaturvedi, the CAG has been in the news more than ever. At present, the 2G scam has continued to keep the media and national focus on then CAG, Vinod Rai. canada goose outlet paypal

canada goose kensington parka uk Thankfully, barring Canada Goose online ex telecom minister A Raja, no one has pointed an accusing finger at Rai. But Chaturvedi colours got when the Opposition BJP made him a Rajya Sabha member canada goose uk outlet on canada goose uk black friday retirement and the Vajpayee government elevated him further as the governor of Opposition ruled Karnataka. Post retirement, M S Gill went on to become a minister of state in UPA I and II regimes of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. Navin Chawla, another UPA appointee, first as EC and later CEC, set off a controversy even when he was in office. canada goose kensington parka uk

canada goose outlet online store review While Seshan made the nation and the world sit up and take note of his reforming the election processes across the country, his quarrels with then Prime Minister buy canada goose jacket Rao were equally well known, though thankfully less remembered and even less frequently recalled in comparison to the good work he had done/initiated. He blotted his copy book even more by first contesting the presidential polls, and later against the BJP L K Advani from Gandhinagar Lok Sabha constituency in Gujarat and on a Congress party ticket. canada goose outlet online store review

canada goose outlet online uk The democratic dictum, wife should be above suspicion does not seem to apply to political parties, leaders and governments at the Centre. Coming at a time when the government is tied down in a never ending battle with the judiciary over the appointment of judges, questions about the need for in one unaffected area of democratic governance while the executive wants to bring others under its smacks of controversy and worse. canada goose outlet online uk

canada goose outlet woodbury When state governments are being blamed for their State Election Commissions, created under the Constitution 74th and 75th Amendments pertaining to panchayati raj, the Centre alone does not seem to want to either create an independent mechanism, or accommodate the existing EC structure in the choice of election commissioners and chief election commissioners. canada goose outlet woodbury

canada goose outlet store quebec A concept has thus allowed to germinate and fester that all that is done by the Union is right and correct, and whatever initiatives taken by state governments (especially those run by parties to the one in power at the Centre) cannot be anything but wrong, improper and inadequate. Such an approach, which is coming to pervade other areas of governmental policy making, including education and healthcare, for instance, intelligence sharing and terrorism investigation, all have a tendency to weaken the nation democratic structure, and thus the much canada goose coats maligned in diversity of the Indian nation and State, which has remained the bedrock of our national and nation uk canada goose outlet State experiment and experience. canada goose outlet store quebec

It is another interesting aspect of Indian democracy that whenever a single political leader is cheap Canada Goose seen to stand taller than all the rest put together, his party starts talking about a form of government through elections The Emergency era options that the ruling Congress explored for Indira Gandhi permanency in power are too well known for repetition.

canada goose outlet houston When Vajpayee was in power, the BJP was talking about the form of governance Now, PM Modi, possibly seeking to cover up for the inadequacies of his regional satraps and their ability to deliver at Canada Goose Parka Election canadian goose jacket 2019, even when the political Opposition continues to be weak and divided, is talking about simultaneous polls, which means the BJP NDA could continue to count on his personal popularity to win assembly polls, without having to fight another poll battle canada goose store of the nerve racking kind in every other state, whether his BJP is in power there or not. canada goose outlet houston

canada goose outlet store near me Likewise, it is yet another irony of Indian democracy that political parties that blame the rulers of the day for misusing and abusing constitutional offices such as canada goose coats on sale the judiciary and the Election Commission, the CAG and now the CVC, have done precious little to de politicise the appointments, elevations and transfers. Individual MPs who take time off to present member bill on a host other issues and concerns, knowing full well that they would not pass canada goose muster, have canada goose black friday sale never ever attempted one on reforming the EC in particular even if it pertained only to future appointments of ECs and the CEC canada goose outlet store near me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *